Overview: Two Different Approaches to Fitness Tracking

Choosing the right fitness app can make or break your health journey. With so many options available in 2025, two apps stand out for different reasons: Fitnit and MyFitnessPal. Let's dive deep into how they compare.

What is MyFitnessPal?

MyFitnessPal has been the industry standard for nutrition tracking since 2005, boasting the world's largest food database with over 14 million foods. It's primarily focused on calorie counting and macro tracking through manual entry.

What is Fitnit?

Fitnit is a newer, AI-powered fitness app that takes a completely different approach. Instead of just tracking what you eat, it uses computer vision technology to automatically track your exercises AND your nutrition through photos.

Head-to-Head Feature Comparison

Exercise Tracking Capabilities

MyFitnessPal Exercise Tracking:

  • Manual entry of exercises required
  • Integration with fitness wearables
  • Basic calorie burn estimates
  • No form feedback or correction

Fitnit Exercise Tracking:

  • Automatic rep counting using AI pose detection
  • Real-time form feedback during exercises
  • Tracks push-ups, squats, crunches, and curls automatically
  • No wearable required – just your phone camera
  • Privacy-focused: video processing happens locally on your device
Winner: Fitnit – The automatic tracking and form feedback is a game-changer for anyone who wants accurate workout data without manual logging.

Nutrition Tracking Showdown

MyFitnessPal Nutrition Features:

  • Massive food database (14+ million items)
  • Barcode scanner for packaged foods
  • Manual entry required for everything
  • Recipe calculator
  • Requires typing and searching

Fitnit Nutrition Features:

  • AI-powered photo recognition
  • Snap a photo of your meal
  • Instant calorie and macro breakdown
  • No manual entry required
  • Works with any food – no database limitations
Winner: Fitnit – While MyFitnessPal has a larger database, Fitnit's photo-based tracking is faster and eliminates the tedious process of searching and logging individual foods.

Ease of Use Comparison

MyFitnessPal User Experience:

  • Steeper learning curve
  • Requires consistent manual logging
  • Can be time-consuming (5-10 minutes per meal)
  • Many users abandon after a few weeks due to logging fatigue

Fitnit User Experience:

  • Point your camera and go
  • Minimal user input required
  • Automatic tracking reduces friction
  • Higher user retention due to simplicity
Winner: Fitnit – Studies show that reducing friction in tracking significantly improves long-term adherence.

Pricing Breakdown

MyFitnessPal Pricing:

  • Free tier with ads and limited features
  • Premium: $19.99/month or $79.99/year
  • Many features locked behind paywall

Fitnit Pricing:

  • Free during beta
  • All features accessible
  • No ads
Winner: Fitnit – Currently free with full feature access.

Privacy and Data Security

MyFitnessPal Privacy Concerns:

  • Data stored on external servers
  • Has experienced data breaches in the past (150 million accounts in 2018)
  • Shares data with third parties

Fitnit Privacy Advantages:

  • Video processing done locally on your device
  • Camera feed never stored or transmitted
  • Only basic workout data stored in your secure account
  • Zero access to your video feed
Winner: Fitnit – Clear privacy advantage with local processing.

Who Should Choose Each App?

Choose MyFitnessPal If You:

  • Need access to a massive packaged food database
  • Prefer typing over taking photos
  • Rely heavily on barcode scanning for packaged foods
  • Are already integrated with the MyFitnessPal ecosystem
  • Want detailed macro tracking for specific diets

Choose Fitnit If You:

  • Want automatic exercise tracking without manual input
  • Are tired of tedious manual food logging
  • Exercise at home with bodyweight movements
  • Value your privacy and data security
  • Want real-time form feedback to prevent injuries
  • Have tried and abandoned traditional calorie counters

The Verdict: Which App Wins in 2025?

While MyFitnessPal remains a solid choice for dedicated calorie counters who don't mind manual entry, Fitnit represents the future of fitness tracking. Its AI-powered approach eliminates the friction that causes most people to abandon fitness apps within weeks.

If you've tried MyFitnessPal before and found the manual logging tedious, Fitnit's automatic tracking might be exactly what you need to finally stick with your fitness goals.

Ready to Try the Smarter Way to Track Fitness?

Sign up for Fitnit free during our beta and experience automatic workout and nutrition tracking powered by AI!